- Grove City, Pennsylvania


June 25, 2014

EXTRA INNINGS: All-Star voting push has gone overboard

OPINION — Clear the deck!

But it’s not a cannonball that’s comin’.

It’s yet another volley from the Pirates’ ill-advised barrage to get center fielder Andrew McCutchen and second baseman Neil Walker elected to this year’s stuff-the-ballot-box exercise known as All-Star game voting.

No Pirate fan doubts the worthiness of McCutchen and Walker as NL starters, and if Pittsburgh fans are going to cast a ballot, can you imagine them NOT voting for those two?

But what about other Pirates? Should a team focus on campaigning for one or two players and ignore the rest? What does Josh Harrison or Russell Martin think about it, especially when one considers their importance to the team?  Not sayin’ that they don’t support McCutchen and Walker, but isn’t baseball a “team” sport?

And what does it say if such a heavy-handed campaign fails to land one or either as a starter?

Like those cardboard billboards stapled on crooked sticks at election time, “Vote For” signs are inescapable anywhere Pirates fans might look. Several times during each televised game, we are shown action shots of Cutch and the Pittsburgh Kid, each one ending in a reminder to vote for the dynamic duo.

Look anywhere inside PNC Park for additional reminders—from the gaudy signs dancing from the railings of the left-field rotunda, to smaller placards visible at every turn.

Announcers gently imply that it will your fault if McCutchen and Walker aren’t starters.

Go on the website, where you are greeted with “Vote Pirates,” a direct link to the on-line ballot, a free-ticket-for-voting offer, and a countdown until it will be too late to cast your 25 on-line ballots—as well as the inside scoop as to how you can “earn a one-time bonus of 10 additional online ballots”!

Paper ballots at ballparks allowed you vote as many times as you wanted, limited only by the stuffing room in your pockets.

In my own exercise in civil disobedience, I once protested the entire fan voting farce by filling out 362 paper ballots. I can’t remember the year, but it was the time Ronny Cedeno collected a total of 362 votes.

All-Star teams were originally selected by managers and fans for the first two all-star games in 1933 and 1934 games. From 1935 through 1946, only managers selected their league’s roster. From 1947 to 1957, fans picked the team's starter line-up and the managers chose the pitchers and the remaining players. From 1958 through 1969, managers, players, and coaches made the All-Star team selections—what would they know? How ridiculous to have the league’s all-stars selected by their peers. And Since 1970, fans have voted for the starters for each team with the managers picking the reserves and pitchers.

If baseball allows fans to pick the starters, why doesn’t it allow us to vote for the pitching staffs, too? Is Aunt Louise smart enough to pick a third baseman but not a left-handed reliever? MLB should dump this typical half-baked plan and go full steam ahead: Form the team with the top three vote getters at each position to form the roster and add the nine starting pitchers and three relievers with the most votes and be done with it.

While voting at ballparks has ended, you can still vote online or on a mobile device at and all 30 team sites until 11:59 p.m. next Thursday, July 3.

But fan voting doesn’t stop there.

Immediately after the 2014 teams are announced next week, fans can begin voting from a list of five players from each league to select the 34th and final player.

And the voting doesn't end there.

The final phase of voting will allow fans to vote for the game’s most valuable player award and will represent 20 percent of the overall vote that picks the winner.

Come to think of it, why should it stop there?

Don’t bother to play the game at all—just let the fans vote for the winner.

Jim Sankey is a baseball columnist for The Allied News.

Text Only
  • On to baseball GC coach Bell retired — sort of!

    You can take the man out of coaching, but you can’t take coaching out of the man.
    Former Grove City High football coach Jeff Bell has spent his first few months of retirement hearing the ping of a baseball ricocheting off an aluminum bat instead of clap of shoulder pads coming together.
    “My grandson Maddox (Bell) and a few of his friends play on a traveling team, so I’m helping out with that,” said Bell, who retired as the Eagles’ football coach this past winter. “They’re a good group of kids to work with and this is a lot more enjoyable. It’s a lot less stress.

    July 30, 2014 1 Photo

  • RANDOM THOUGHTS: Pouncey latest Steeler to make court news

    HERE I THOUGHT, we were going to make it through an offseason without a Pittsburgh Steeler getting in trouble for something stupid.
    Thanks Maurkice Pouncey for allowing that to not happen.
    I just love seeing Steelers players in the police blotter or on the court docket (tongue firmly in cheek).

    July 30, 2014

  • EXTRA INNINGS: Forget trade deadline, focus on signing Martin

    WHILE BASEBALL fans are focused on tomorrow’s 4 p.m. EDT non-waiver trade deadline, there is an issue that is even more pressing for the Pirates: re-signing catcher Russell Martin, eligible for free agency after the 2014 season.
    Andrew McCutcheon is the team’s most valuable player, but Martin is the most valuable TO the Pirates. It is no coincidence that the Pirates’ return to the postseason last year occurred in Martin’s first year with the Bucs.

    July 30, 2014

  • NCAA Football: Rock 6-1 after 17-3 win over Cal U

    Slippery Rock University rode a length-of-the-field scoring drive by its offense and a goal-line stand by its No. 1-ranked defense late in the first half of action Saturday to a 17-3 win over 14th-ranked visiting California (Pa.).

    October 19, 2011

  • steez pc.jpg NFL: Steelers top Jags as Mendenhall makes return

    Mike Tomlin isn’t ready to say the Pittsburgh Steelers are back. Not after watching his team sleepwalk through the second half against Jacksonville on Sunday.

    October 19, 2011 1 Photo

  • wheldon, dan pc.jpg IndyCar Racing: Crash takes Wheldon’s life

    Every race car driver heads onto the track understanding this race could be the last and hoping it won’t be. On Sunday, IndyCar drivers got a harsh reminder when the worst happened to one of their own.

    October 19, 2011 3 Photos

  • pens pc.jpg NHL: Sabres beat Penguins 3-2

    The Buffalo Sabres have had trouble with the Pittsburgh Penguins whether Sidney Crosby and Evgeni Malkin play or not.

    October 19, 2011 1 Photo

  • canadiens logo pc.jpg NHL Quick glance: Montreal at Pittsburgh

    A breakdown of the National Hockey League game Thursday night between the Pittsburgh Penguins and visiting Montreal Canadiens.

    October 19, 2011 4 Photos

  • High School Highlights: Oct. 19, 2011

    A look at the last few days in local high school fall sports action.

    October 19, 2011

  • washington, ron pc.jpg Leading Off: Oct. 19, 2011

    News and notes from the local, regional and national sports scene.

    October 19, 2011 5 Photos

Featured Ads
Hyperlocal Search
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide