- Grove City, Pennsylvania


September 24, 2011

Studies show, not all studies are created equal

GROVE CITY — Did you know that "people who made a point of looking at flowers first thing in the morning reported feeling cheerier and even more energetic throughout the day, according to a recent study?"

The quote is from a past issue of Woman's Day and I want us to take a closer look at those last five words: "According to a recent study." I searched the pages of the magazine for the source of this "recent study" and it might not surprise you to hear that there was no source listed. I wanted to know the methodology used to conduct such a study but since I couldn't find the source, I'll have to use my imagination.

Firstly, what authority might have conducted the recent study? Woman's Day magazine is geared toward women, so it's probably not too far fetched to say that a women's gardening club may have carried out the study. I know a few members of The Herb Thymers, an all-ladies herb gardening group. Do you think they'd have expertise enough to conduct such a study as the one in Woman's Day? Maybe.

Secondly, who were those people in the recent study, and was there a control group? It's well known in scientific (and botanical) communities that in order to conduct a proper recent study, one must have a control group or you might think those "people who made a point of looking at flowers first thing in the morning" were all avid gardeners. It doesn't take a genius to figure out that avid gardeners like me and you would feel cheerier looking at flowers morning, noon, and night.

A third point I'd like to bring up is the supposed level of energy or cheer one maintains after looking at flowers first thing in the morning. I think most folks would be easily cheered or energized after waking to see a bouquet of flowers rather than a bowl of mud, or a rotten banana. And the recent study gave no indication if the participants were allowed to choose what they would see upon waking.

Might the recent study be flawed for not measuring whether or not participants were just as cheered or energized when allowed to see their wives or husbands first thing in the morning?

Finally, you're probably thinking that I'm carrying this "recent study" thing a bit too far. That may be true, but the point I'm trying to make is that sometimes writers might use terms like "user opinions," "recent studies," "unscientific surveys," (one of my favorites), and similar phrases to enhance, embellish, persuade and prompt. This isn't necessarily a bad thing, because user opinions will vary depending on whatever recent study or unscientific survey they might have consulted.

One last note: If measuring energy and cheeriness of flowers were possible, it wouldn't surprise me in the least if they became much less so after viewing my face the first thing in the morning!

T.C. Conner is a Master Gardener and columnist for Allied News. He can be reached at Check out his blog at www.the His new book, "Through the Seasons with The Write Gardener," is available for sale at Allied News.

Text Only
  • GC HS alum serving togethe.jpg Trio of GCHS alums serve together as officers

    CDR Raymond Batz, MC, USN, wing surgeon, Second Marine Aircraft Wing (2d MAW) and 1988 graduate of Grove City Area High School and 1992 graduate of Grove City College, was surprised to find two other GCHS graduates -- Lt. Col. Bill 'Kelvin' Sauerland and Lt. Ian Uber -- among the officers of 2d MAW on the same base near Havelock, N.C., often at the same meeting.

    March 28, 2014 1 Photo

  • Sonny Myers reopens auto shop

    After a devastating fire last year that took the livelihood out of Sonny Myers of Myers Auto Repair, he has reopened to do inspections and mechanical work.

    February 21, 2014

  • Learn to keep well water safe

    Registration is now open for free National Ground Water Association webinars to help household water well owners keep their water safe.
    The toll-free private well owner hotline at 855-420-9355. There are free online well owner lessons on about a variety of topics relating to water wells, including water quality.

    January 27, 2014

  • bw bobbiejocomes mug.jpg Polar plunge helps charities; bike winners announced

    Freezin’ for a Reason attracted hundreds of plungers and spectators at the Allegheny River as part of the 8th annual Parker Polar Bear Club Plunge on New Year’s Day.

    January 17, 2014 2 Photos

  • Double feature: Cash mob helps Guthrie Double feature: Cash mob helps Guthrie

    The Guthrie Theatre was cash mobbed on Saturday, Dec. 21, when 16 adults and 2 kids gathered at 10:30 a.m. at the Grove City Chamber of Commerce and then proceeded to the historic Broad Street theater

    January 3, 2014 1 Photo

  • com scrap-gchs reunion.jpg GC class celebrates 50th with teachers, plan scholarship/gift

    The Grove City High School class of 1963 celebrated their 50th anniversary of graduation with a weekend packed with activities for all classmates and their spouses to enjoy.

    December 3, 2013 1 Photo

  • Stop, Shop and Dine Olde Town, GJR accepting donations for Sculpture Signage Project

    Currently, six sculptures stand on Broad and South Center streets, designating parking for incoming visitors. Every year Olde Town collects donations from Olde Town businesses and the community.

    November 19, 2013 1 Photo

  • Fifty Years of Pipes and Drums Pipes and drums

    Commencing with the rich “skirling” of bagpipes, The Grove City Historical Society hosted the final seminar of the 2013 season, “Fifty Years of Pipes and Drums”

    November 9, 2013 1 Photo

  • Milestone birthday Dorothy Henderson celebrates 97th birthday

    Dorothy Mae McCandless Henderson, of Grove Manor, 435 N. Broad St., Grove City, who has lived in the borough since 1978, recently celebrated her 97th birthday.

    November 8, 2013 1 Photo

  • Down Syndrome Awareness Extra special

    Because National Down Syndrome Awareness Month is a celebration of special people, Polly Lindh put up a display at Beans on Broad to let others know that there are several in the community “rockin’ an extra chromosome.”

    November 8, 2013 1 Photo

Featured Ads
Hyperlocal Search
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide